
Before you know it, your baby will need a toddler car seat. It’ll seem like it was only yesterday when you brought him home from the hospital in an infant seat. Those first few years pass quickly! Soon it’s time for your little guy or gal to get a whole new view of the world.
The switch from rear-facing to forward-facing is a big milestone in your child’s life. But like every milestone, it brings about a slew of new questions for you. When should you make the switch? Which toddler seats are safest, and which will fit in your car best? Which ones best fit your budget?
We’ll answer those questions and more to help make your choice as simple as possible.
What Types of Toddler Car Seats are Available?
There are two main types of toddler car seats. Before shopping try to think about what will work best for your lifestyle.
1. Convertible car seats: This is a very popular option that can even be used from the time your child is a newborn. These seats start out rear-facing, then convert around to a forward-facing seat and very often even into a booster seat. There are a few drawbacks to convertible seats, the main one being that they’re heavy. Also, they can't be used as an infant carrier and don’t have a static base you can install like an infant seat, so switching from car to car means installing and uninstalling each time. However, these seats can save you money in the long run since you won’t need to buy multiple car seats as your child grows.
2. Forward-facing car seats: These seats will keep your child safe in a 5-point harness but will allow her to sit more naturally and interact with you easier. You can also see her better in the rearview mirror. Many forward-facing seats are simply one mode of a convertible seat, while others do double duty as forward-facing and booster modes. Very few seats are only a forward-facing harness.
When should we make the switch from rear-facing to a toddler seat?

The official definition of a toddler is a child who is 12 to 36 months old (1-3 years), but when it comes to toddler seats, this definition has a wider range. The AAP recommends keeping your child rear-facing as long as possible up to the 4th birthday. Car seat manufacturers are making this possible with new, larger weight limits, up to 50 - 55 pounds. So, it’s now possible for you to keep a 3-5 year old child rear-facing for an extended period of time depending on their size.
We’ll talk more about the AAP recommendations, and consider which car seats are most appropriate for specific age groups below.
If your toddler is 12-24 months:
In this age range, ideally, your child should remain rear-facing. However, height and weight can vary greatly from child to child. So, the best seat choice in this range is a convertible seat. If your child is on the high side of the growth chart, you can easily switch them to forward-facing when they reach the max weight and/or height limit for rear-facing (at least 24 months and 40+ pounds for most seats).
Check out our list of some of the top-rated best convertible car seats.
You may think that this is a bit long to keep your child rear-facing, but recently the AAP changed its recommendation to say that kids should be rear-facing for as long as possible up to age 4. Here is a snippet of that, and you can read the whole article here.
November 2018 issue of Pediatrics (published online Aug. 30), the AAP recommends children remain in a rear-facing car safety seat as long as possible, until they reach the highest weight or height allowed by their seat. Previously, the AAP specified children should remain rear-facing at least to age 2; the new recommendation removes the specific age milestone.
“Fortunately, car seat manufacturers have created seats that allow children to remain rear-facing until they weigh 40 pounds or more, which means most children can remain rear-facing past their second birthday,” said Benjamin Hoffman, MD, FAAP, lead author of the policy statement and chair of the AAP Council on Injury, Violence and Poison Prevention. “It’s best to keep your child rear-facing as long as possible. This is still the safest way for children to ride.”
Best Convertible Toddler Car Seat for Kids 12-24 months
For maximum safety and comfort: extended rear-facing (up to 50 pounds), then converts to harnessed forward-facing (up to 65 pounds) and finally to a highback booster, so you won't need to buy a separate booster later.
Graco Extend2Fit 3-in-1
Price: Average
The Graco Extend2Fit 3-in-1 is a top pick for parents who want extended rear-facing and one seat that lasts into the booster years.
What we like
The 50 pound rear-facing limit is one of the highest you'll find, and the extension panel gives growing legs room to stay rear-facing longer. Unlike the original 2-in-1 Extend2Fit, this version also converts to a highback booster, so you won't need to buy a separate booster later.
The no-rethread Simply Safe Adjust harness moves the harness and headrest together as your child grows. It has a 10-position headrest, a 6-position recline, InRight LATCH with push-on connectors and two cup holders. The seat is certified to FMVSS 213 and is FAA-certified for aircraft in harness modes.
Worth knowing
This is a big seat. Graco lists it at 19 in wide, and retailers list it at about 20.6 pounds, so it's rarely a three-across choice and isn't one to move between cars often. The rear-facing lower-anchor limit is 40 pounds, so heavier rear-facing kids need a seat-belt install, and reviewers find belt installs harder because there's no lock-off.
It isn't a snug fit for preemies or very small newborns, the cup holders must stay attached, and it isn't FAA-certified in booster mode. It also costs more than the original Extend2Fit 2-in-1.
What parents say
Reviewers and car seat technicians rate the Extend2Fit 3-in-1 highly for extended rear-facing and like that the harness is easy to adjust as a child grows. The most common complaints are the seat's width and weight, a tricky rear-facing seat-belt install, a harness some parents find stiff to tighten, and cup holders that are hard to remove.
Other versions: Graco also sells an Extend2Fit 3-in-1 featuring an Anti-Rebound Bar for rear-facing use, and the original Extend2Fit 2-in-1 (no booster mode) is still available for families on a tighter budget.
Graco 4Ever DLX 4-in-1
Price: Average
The Graco 4Ever DLX 4-in-1 is the updated version of the 4Ever, our long-time favorite one-and-done seat.
What we like
Four modes cover 4 pounds rear-facing to a 120 pound backless booster, so this can be the only car seat many families buy. Compared with the original 4Ever, the DLX adds a built-in belt lock-off for forward-facing seat-belt installs and a RapidRemove seat pad that comes off for washing without uninstalling the seat.
The no-rethread harness adjusts with the headrest, the lower anchors can be used for the full rear-facing range and to 45 pounds forward-facing, and the highback booster can use them too (to 100 pounds) if your vehicle maker allows. The seat is certified to FMVSS 213 and is FAA-certified for aircraft in harness modes.
Worth knowing
This is a big, heavy seat. Graco lists it at 21.5 in wide (car seat technicians measured an earlier DLX at about 19.5 in at the cup holders), and retailers list it at about 23 pounds. It isn't a three-across seat, and the cup holders must stay installed.
The 40 pound rear-facing limit is lower than 50 pound seats like the Extend2Fit, the lower anchors can't be used in backless booster mode, and it isn't FAA-certified as a booster. With a 10-year life, it may expire before a child who starts in it at birth is done with boosters.
What parents say
Car seat technicians and testers like the DLX's easy lower-anchor install and its belt lock-off, and see it as a close update of the original 4Ever. The most common complaints are its width and weight, a cover that can still be fiddly to remove and put back, rough fabric, and a forward-facing recline that can push the headrest into the vehicle seat in some cars.
Other versions: Graco also sells a slimmer 4Ever DLX Slim 4-in-1 for families who need to fit three seats across.
Browse more convertible car seats→
If your toddler is 24+ months (and ~40+ pounds):
At this size and age, a convertible car seat wouldn’t be practical. Instead, you should invest in a front-facing, harnessed seat. The best option is a forward-facing/booster combo. Some of these are 3 -in- 1 seats that can convert from a harnessed seat to a belt-positioning highback booster and then into a backless booster seat. Those will often give you the most value for the money.
Here’s a little rundown of the different seat types & combos available:
- Harnessed forward-facing seats: Your child should ride in a 5-point harness seat until she’s outgrown that seat or mode and is ready for a booster seat. Parents shouldn’t be in a rush to switch to a booster. Most 3 and even 4 year olds aren’t behaviorally ready to sit in a booster seat with only the vehicle seat belt to contain them. You know your child best. If he or she is about to outgrow their harnessed seat AND is mature enough to sit still with the seat belt alone, then you can safely make the switch to a booster.
- Belt-positioning (high back) boosters: These are often the best boosters to transition to after a harnessed seat. They keep kids positioned correctly when they’re asleep and help position the seat belt better on the shoulders of smaller children.
- Backless boosters: These seats boost your child higher up so that the vehicle seat belt fits better. Backless booster seats don’t provide any back or head support. Your child must have some head support from the vehicle behind them in order to ride in a backless booster. They’re best for kids that don’t often fall asleep in the car since they don’t keep them from slumping over. Backless boosters, however, are usually the cheapest type and they are very light and easy to move from car to car.
Many of these come in combinations of harnessed forward-facing seat and a high back booster or in a combo of all 3. The combos grow with your child and can easily last for several siblings. Check out our list of the best forward-facing car seats.
Best Toddler Car Seat for Kids 24+ months
Harnessed forward-facing car seat and high back belt-positioning booster in one, with Britax's ClickTight seat-belt install: a 5-point harness from 30 to 65 pounds, then a booster up to 120 pounds.
Britax Grow With You ClickTight
Price: High
The Britax Grow With You ClickTight is the closest current Britax harness-to-booster to the retired Frontier ClickTight.
What we like
ClickTight turns a seat-belt install into opening a panel, buckling the belt and closing it, and the manual calls it the preferred method. One seat covers a 30 pound toddler to a 120 pound big kid, with a booster mode up to 63 in.
The 9-position no-rethread harness and headrest grow with your child (harness slots 12 to 20 in). A SafeWash machine-washable cover comes on select fashions, and it has a 9-year useful life, two cup and snack holders and aircraft certification in harness mode.
Worth knowing
The harness stops at 65 pounds and 49 in, well below the retired Frontier's 90 pounds and 58 in, so big or tall kids move to booster mode sooner. It must ride upright in harness mode from 40 pounds, and the lower anchors stop at 40 pounds in harness mode.
At 19 in wide and 25 pounds, it isn't a three-across or car-swapping seat, and car seat technicians warn that fixed, forward-tilting vehicle headrests can interfere. Reviewers found the buckle clips fiddly and the shoulder belt can slip from its guide in booster mode. It sits in Britax's premium price band.
What parents say
Car seat technicians and reviewers (Car Seats for the Littles, Safe in the Seat, BabyGearLab) like the ClickTight seat-belt install and the long booster range. The most common complaints are the seat's size and weight, vehicle headrest interference, fiddly crotch-buckle clips and, in booster mode, a hard-to-reach buckle and a shoulder belt that can slip from its guide. BabyGearLab rated its crash testing of an earlier production seat only slightly above average.
Other versions: the Britax Grow With You (no ClickTight) is a separate, current model without the ClickTight panel. The Grow With You ClickTight Plus is retired.
Full list of the best booster seats of 2021→
Best Belt-positioning 2-in-1 Booster for Toddlers 4 and up
Best long-lasting booster for children who hate 5 point harnesses; starts as high back and then transforms to backless booster.
Chicco KidFit ClearTex Plus 2-in-1 Belt-Positioning Booster
Price: Average
The Chicco KidFit ClearTex Plus 2-in-1 is Chicco's current version of its popular KidFit booster.
What we like
One seat covers both stages: high-back from 40 to 100 pounds, then backless up to 110 pounds, with a 44-57 inch height range in both modes. The headrest adjusts to 10 height positions, and the backrest has 2 recline positions to match your vehicle seat.
LATCH is optional and keeps the booster in place when kids climb in, and the new pull handle makes it easy to release. The cover is machine washable, the cup holders are dishwasher safe, and there are no recalls on any KidFit.
Worth knowing
The 44-inch minimum height is higher than the original KidFit's 38 inches, so many younger 4-year-olds won't fit it yet. The 57-inch maximum is lower than some newer boosters.
It's wide (about 18.4-19 inches as measured by testers), so it isn't a 3-across seat, and fixed, forward-tilting vehicle head restraints can rule out high-back mode. You still need to buckle it with the seat belt whenever it's empty. It has no IIHS rating of its own, and like every booster it isn't FAA certified.
What parents say
Testers and car seat techs describe it as the same proven KidFit with new fabric and a new LATCH release. BabyGearLab found the headrest fabric a little rough and said the buckle can rub on the booster's side, so some kids need an extra pull to unbuckle. Safe in the Seat measured it at about 19 inches wide, and CarSeatsForTheLittles notes that fixed, forward-tilting vehicle head restraints can get in the way of high-back mode and that its 57-inch top height is lower than some newer boosters.
Best high back boosters→
Toddler Car Seat Safety Guide

Avoid these common mistakes
- Buying a car seat without doing your research. That’s why we’re here. It’s hard to figure out what’s what when shopping around, so we have all the info you need in one place.
- Putting the car seat in the wrong spot. The safest place for a car seat is ALWAYS the back seat, away from airbags. Where you put it back there depends on several things, which we’ll discuss below.
- Incorrectly installing your car seat. First time parents should look for easy-to-install seats that take the guesswork out and make you less prone to make mistakes. A car seat is only effective if it is installed correctly.
- Incorrect recline angle. Small babies must be at the proper recline so their airways are kept open. Always follow the car seat manufacturer’s instructions on how to properly recline the seat.
- Switching to forward-facing too soon. The AAP recommends keeping your child rear-facing for as long as possible up to age 4. Many car seats now have higher weight limits to allow for extended rear-facing.
- Too much clothing on your child. Always remove your child’s bulky coats and blankets before buckling them in the car seat, or the straps won’t provide a snug enough fit. Buckle them in, THEN cover them up.
- Switching to a booster seat too soon. If your child is under 4 years old, under 40 pounds, and still needs help buckling in, they are NOT ready for a belt-positioning booster. Wait until he’s mature enough to buckle himself and sit still for the entire ride.
- Using a booster seat incorrectly. Booster seats need both a lap and shoulder belt. The lap belt should lie across the thighs and not the abdomen. The shoulder belt should lie diagonally across the chest and shoulder and not against the neck.
- Switching to a vehicle seat belt too soon. Keep your child in a booster until they are at least 8-12 years old and until they reach 4 feet, 9 inches in height. When they can sit up straight with legs bent comfortably over the edge of the back seat and when the seat belt fits them correctly without a booster, then they’re ready.
Remember - the safest place for kids age 13 and under is always the BACK SEAT!
What is the most comfortable car seat for toddlers?
That really depends on your child’s size and preferences, along with how long they’ll be riding. If you take extended road trips, opting for a more plush, padded seat might be best. But if you have a toddler who hates feeling closed in, a less-padded seat might help them feel less constrained.

Car seats with wide wings for good head and neck support are popular choices with parents. Some toddlers fall asleep within minutes after you start driving, so it’s important to keep them from slumping over, especially if they’ll be in a belt-positioning booster. Avoid switching to a booster seat for as long as possible, as a five-point harness will help to hold them up much better.
One of the most comfortable car seats we reviewed was the original Graco 4Ever All-in-One (Graco's current version is the 4Ever DLX 4-in-1). Many parents reported how comfortable this seat was for their child. Some babies who previously cried in other seats didn’t when they switched to this one.
Where is the safest place for a toddler car seat?
Studies have shown that putting a car seat in the center rear seat is 43% safer than a side position. Most parents, however, put their children in the rear passenger side since this helps the driver keep an eye on the child easier with just a quick glance. It also makes loading and unloading easier.
Also, some older cars only have LATCH on the two side seating positions. Keep in mind, though, that it’s perfectly safe to install your car seat in the center rear position with a seat belt installation. Car seats can only be installed with one or the other, and LATCH is not shown to be any safer than a seat belt installation.
The most important thing to remember is to get a CORRECT installation, no matter where or how you install your car seat. If a car seat is installed incorrectly, it won’t protect your child in any position.
What if you have more than one child in a car seat? Where should you place them?
If you’re expecting or already have a second child, where you place them in the back seat depends on a few different things. Namely, the age and weight of your child. Some experts recommend putting the youngest child in the center seating position. It is the safest position and at a young age they are the most vulnerable to injury due to their more fragile spinal column.
Others recommend putting an older, forward-facing child in the center position with a rear-facing child on the side since rear-facing seats better protect the child’s spinal column. In fact, a rear-facing car seat is shown to be 5 times safer in a front impact crash.
For side-impact crashes, the center seating position is the safest, but these crashes are more rare than front impact crashes. Also, a rear-facing seat isn’t that much safer than a forward-facing seat in the event of a side impact crash.
So, generally, we would recommend putting the youngest child in the center seat. But again, there is no unsafe spot in the backseat so long as the car seat is installed properly. These decisions can all be impacted by different factors beyond a child’s age. If mom had a c-section, for instance, she may have a hard time getting the baby in and out of a car seat that’s in the center position. Parents in the city like the car seat behind the passenger seat so that they don’t have to go into the busy street.
What if you have more than two children who need to ride in car seats?
If you’re expecting a THIRD child, and all three will be in car seats, the biggest challenge is simply whether you can actually fit 3 car seats in your vehicle. If you have a smaller car, look for car seats with narrow profiles that customers have successfully used in a 3-across configuration.
For narrow seats and tips on making three fit, see our guide to fitting car seats three across.
What car seat is suitable for a 2 year old?

Depending on your child’s size, it’s safest for a 2-year-old to ride rear-facing for as long as possible. Seats such as the Graco Extend2Fit 3-in-1 are perfect for this. It rear-faces up to 50 pounds and has an extension panel to keep legs from getting cramped. When your child does outgrow rear-facing, it turns forward-facing with a harness (26.5 pounds minimum, per the manual) and later becomes a highback booster.
Any rear-facing or combination car seat that allows for extended rear-facing is great for this age since the AAP recommends keeping them rear-facing for as long as possible beyond 2 years old. Also, 2-year-olds should always be in a harnessed seat at this age and never in a seat belt positioning booster. They simply aren’t old enough to be trusted with a regular seat belt.
What car seat is suitable for a 3 year old?

Many 3-year-olds are eager for a forward-facing seat but they maybe don't meet the minimum weight and height requirements. It is safest for children to stay rear facing for as long as possible, up to age 4. You can start with a combination seat when they’re newborns and switch to forward-facing when they’ve reached the right size range. Or you can get them a combo forward-facing and booster seat after they’ve outgrown an infant seat.
Again, keep them in a harnessed seat for as long as possible. It is safer for your 3-year-olds to travel in forward facing car seat. Car seats like the Britax Grow With You ClickTight are great for this older age group since they start as a forward-facing harnessed seat (30 to 65 pounds, per the manual). They can then be converted to a seat-belt positioning booster when you feel your child is mature enough.