Best Car Seat Hub

Car seats, checked against the manual — not the marketing.

convertible seat

Britax Poplar Convertible Car Seat Review

by britax

Britax Poplar convertible car seat in Stone Onyx, front three-quarter view with cup holders
Image: Britax
Our rating9.3/10

The Britax Poplar pairs Britax's easy ClickTight seat-belt install with a slim 17 in shell and a 50 lb rear-facing limit, making it the Britax convertible we'd pick for most families, as long as your vehicle headrests don't get in the way.

Fits your child
  • Rear-facing
  • Forward-facing

What we like

The 50 pound rear-facing limit is 10 pounds more than the Marathon ClickTight's, so most children can stay rear-facing much longer. ClickTight turns a seat-belt install into opening a panel, buckling the belt and closing it, with no need to lock the vehicle belt.

At 17 in wide, it's 1.5 in slimmer than the Marathon and a candidate for crowded back rows. It has 6 recline positions, a lower infant insert for babies up to 20 pounds, two dishwasher-safe cup holders and a 10-year useful life.

Worth knowing

Car seat technicians warn that vehicle headrests often get in the way forward-facing, so it's a poor fit for cars with fixed headrests. At 27.2 pounds, it's heavy to move between cars, and the lower anchors stop at 35 pounds in both directions.

Reviewers found the ClickTight panel can take force to close and the cover hard to put back on after washing. There's no booster mode, and the anti-rebound bar only comes with the pricier Poplar S. Britax doesn't approve any vehicle seat protector for it.

❮ More Convertible Seats

Looking for the Britax Marathon ClickTight? Britax has retired it. Its product page now reads “This product has been retired,” and it’s no longer in Britax’s convertible lineup. That’s why our old Marathon review now brings you here.

The Britax Poplar is the closest current Britax ClickTight convertible to the retired Marathon. Like the Marathon, it’s a harness-only seat that rides rear-facing and then forward-facing, and it installs with Britax’s ClickTight seat-belt system. Britax doesn’t call it a replacement for the Marathon, but if you liked the Marathon, this is the seat in Britax’s lineup that does the same job today.

It also improves on it in two ways that matter. It rear-faces to 50 pounds (the Marathon stopped at 40), and it’s 17 inches wide, 1.5 inches slimmer than the Marathon. Every limit on this page comes from Britax’s current owner’s manual, P15154500_A.1 (May 2025).

Our verdict: if you want a seat-belt install that’s hard to get wrong, a long rear-facing runway and a seat narrow enough for a crowded back row, the Poplar is an excellent pick. Check your vehicle headrests first.

Key features of the Britax Poplar

  • ClickTight installation: you open a panel, buckle the vehicle seat belt through it and close it. The manual calls this the “Preferred Method.”
  • Rear-facing from 5 to 50 lb
  • 17 in wide (“Slim 17” Design,“ per Britax)
  • 6 recline positions with a recline indicator
  • A lower infant insert and a positioning layer for small babies
  • Two removable, dishwasher-safe cup holders
  • Aircraft-certified, with a 10-year useful life

What changed from the Britax Marathon ClickTight

The Poplar is a different shell with different limits, not a refreshed Marathon. Here’s how they compare, according to Britax’s owner’s manuals.

Chart comparing Britax Marathon ClickTight and Britax Poplar weight ranges: Marathon rear-facing 5 to 40 lb and forward-facing 20 to 65 lb; Poplar rear-facing 5 to 50 lb and forward-facing 30 to 65 lb

Marathon ClickTight Poplar
Status Retired Current
Modes Rear- and forward-facing harness Rear- and forward-facing harness (same)
Rear-facing 5–40 lb 5–50 lb, 18–49 in
Forward-facing 20–65 lb, 49 in or less 30–65 lb, 35–49 in
Lower anchors 35 lb rear-facing, 40 lb forward-facing 35 lb both ways
Width 18.5 in 17 in
ClickTight panel Press-and-rotate dial Squeeze buttons
Recline 7 positions 6 positions
Anti-rebound bar On select models On the Poplar S
FAA / useful life Aircraft-certified / 10 years Aircraft-certified / 10 years (same)

The big change is 10 more pounds of rear-facing. The Poplar goes to 50 lb, so most children can stay rear-facing much longer, which is where safety experts want them.

Forward-facing now starts later: 30 lb, up from 20 lb. Your child also has to be at least 35 in tall. That’s a stricter rule, and a good one: it keeps kids rear-facing longer.

The forward-facing lower-anchor limit dropped from 40 to 35 lb. Past 35 lb, in either direction, you install with the seat belt, which with ClickTight is the easier method anyway.

It’s narrower, and ClickTight opens differently. The Poplar is 1.5 in slimmer than the Marathon. And instead of pressing and rotating a dial to open the ClickTight panel, you squeeze two release buttons.

Why some sources say 22 lb and others 30 lb to forward-face

Britax’s launch press release and the earliest Poplar seats (model numbers starting E1C93) list forward-facing from 22 lb. The current manual, for models starting E1D22 and E1D42, says 30 lb. If you already own a Poplar, follow the label and manual that came with your seat. Either way, rear-facing to 50 lb is the safer choice.

Still have a Marathon ClickTight?

The Marathon is retired, not recalled, so you don’t have to replace a seat that’s still in date. Britax’s rule is to stop using it once it’s older than 10 years or after a moderate or severe crash. Check the date label on your seat.

One recall to know about. A 2015 recall covered Advocate, Boulevard and Marathon ClickTight seats made from August 1, 2014 to July 29, 2015. The harness adjuster button could stay in the release position, and Britax offered a free remedy kit. Those seats are now also past their 10-year life. If yours falls in that range, check with Britax or NHTSA, and see our car seat recalls page.

Other versions: the Poplar S

The Poplar S is the same seat with the same limits, plus a few extras. It adds a ReboundReduce stability bar, which is used rear-facing only and must be removed for forward-facing, and it adds an upper-body support pillow and a removable head pad. It weighs 28 lb, about 0.8 lb more than the Poplar, and costs more. It’s the closest match to the Marathon models that came with an anti-rebound bar. Choose it if you want the bar; otherwise the base Poplar gives you the same limits and install.

What are the child size limits of the Britax Poplar?

Mode Weight Height and fit rules
Rear-facing harness 5–50 lb 18–49 in; top of head at least 1 in below the top of the head restraint; straps in the closest position below the shoulders
Forward-facing harness 30–65 lb 35–49 in; tops of ears below the top of the head restraint; straps in the closest position above the shoulders

Your child must meet both the weight and the height minimums before you turn the seat forward-facing. Britax “strongly recommends that children ride rear-facing to the highest weight or height specified.”

The Poplar comes with two comfort parts for smaller children, each with its own rules in the manual:

  • Lower infant insert: may be used rear-facing for babies up to 20 lb. Never use it over 20 lb or forward-facing.
  • Positioning layer: must be folded down rear-facing from 5 to 40 lb, and forward-facing from 30 to 40 lb. Above 40 lb, it can be up or down.

A baby who doesn’t have head and neck control rides in the most reclined position. Read more on why rear-facing height and weight limits matter.

How big is the Britax Poplar, and will it fit in your vehicle?

Britax Poplar convertible car seat in Stone Onyx, front view showing the headrest, harness and cup holders

Image: Britax

Britax lists the Poplar at 17 in wide, with product dimensions of 20.5 x 17 x 23.5 in and a seat weight of 27.2 lb. That’s narrow for a ClickTight seat, but it’s not light. Plan to install it once and leave it.

Britax markets the Poplar for three-across setups but can’t guarantee fit in every vehicle. Car Seats for the Littles found it worked best next to other narrow seats, but it didn’t fit their test minivan’s middle seat. Measure your back row first.

Check your vehicle headrests. The manual warns that a vehicle head restraint can stop the seat’s headrest from rising. Car Seats for the Littles found the headrests interfered forward-facing in every vehicle they tried, and both they and Safe in the Seat suggest skipping this seat if your headrests are fixed or can’t be removed.

How safe is the Britax Poplar?

According to the manual, the Poplar “conforms to all applicable Federal motor vehicle safety standards.” Britax builds it with a steel frame, a SafeCell base designed to absorb crash energy and a V-shaped tether with staged-release stitching for forward-facing use.

Britax’s own materials don’t make a side-impact certification claim. CPST sites such as Safe in the Seat list current production as meeting the new federal side-impact standard. If that matters to you, check the label on your seat.

BabyGearLab rated its crash analysis of the Poplar S only average among the convertibles it compared. That’s one outlet’s view of an earlier production seat, but worth knowing.

The Poplar’s biggest safety advantage is how long it keeps your child rear-facing: up to 50 lb and 49 in.

Recalls: we found no recall for the Poplar in NHTSA’s database as of the review date. Register your seat with Britax, and check nhtsa.gov/recalls with your model number.

How easy is the Britax Poplar to install and use?

ClickTight makes the seat-belt install the easy one. You open the panel, route and buckle the vehicle belt, and close the panel. The manual calls this the preferred method in both directions, and you don’t need to lock the vehicle’s seat belt. Car Seats for the Littles notes that the panel can take a bit of force to close.

The other install rules:

  • Lower anchors: up to 35 lb child weight, rear- and forward-facing. Safe in the Seat and BabyGearLab both found the lower-anchor install the weaker option, so most parents will prefer ClickTight.
  • Top tether: forward-facing only, never rear-facing. Britax strongly recommends using it forward-facing.
  • Lap-belt-only installs are allowed, with the vehicle belt locked.
  • Up to 3 in of the base can hang over the front edge of the vehicle seat.
  • Never install it rear-facing in front of an active airbag.

Everyday use: a recline indicator shows the right zone for each direction. BabyGearLab found the cover hard to put back on after washing and the harness release hard to find.

Travel: the Poplar is certified for aircraft. It isn’t compatible with inflatable aircraft seat belts. See our guide to flying with a car seat.

Britax Poplar vs the alternatives

Graco Extend2Fit 3-in-1: it also rear-faces to 50 lb, adds a legroom panel and a highback booster mode, and costs less. It’s wider, though (19 in), and has no lock-off, so belt installs take more work. Choose it for booster years on a budget; choose the Poplar for the slimmer shell and the easier belt install.

Clek Fllo: the other narrow three-across favorite, at about the same width, in a higher price band.

Chicco Fit360: the rotating pick, with an easy self-tensioning belt install, in a higher price band. It rear-faces to 40 lb (the Poplar goes to 50), and at 18.25 in wide with a deep rear-facing footprint it’s a harder fit in a tight back row. NHTSA has an open investigation into its magnetic chest clip.

Britax One4Life Slim: Britax’s all-in-one, for parents who want booster mode from the same seat.


Optional Accessories

Keep it simple with this seat. The manual says not to use non-Britax covers, inserts, toys or other accessories, and not to put anything under the seat that raises it off the vehicle seat. Britax doesn’t approve any vehicle seat protector for this seat, so skip the mats and liners.

If you want an anti-rebound bar, buy the Poplar S, which comes with the ReboundReduce stability bar.


BestCarSeatHub’s Final Verdict

pros

  • Rear-faces up to 50 lb and 49 in
  • ClickTight seat-belt install is hard to get wrong
  • Slim 17 in shell
  • Lower infant insert and positioning layer for small babies
  • Certified for aircraft
  • 10-year useful life

cons

  • Vehicle headrests often interfere forward-facing
  • Heavy (27.2 lb)
  • Lower anchors stop at 35 lb in both directions
  • ClickTight panel can take force to close
  • Cover is hard to reinstall after washing
  • No booster mode
  • The anti-rebound bar is only on the pricier Poplar S

Who it’s for

Parents who want an easy, solid seat-belt install and a long rear-facing runway in a narrow seat. It’s also the natural next seat for families who loved the Marathon ClickTight.

Who should skip it

  • Families with fixed or non-removable vehicle headrests. Check fit forward-facing before you buy.
  • Parents who move the seat between cars often. At 27.2 lb, it’s a chore to carry.
  • Families who want one seat through the booster years. Look at an all-in-one instead.
  • Parents who want an anti-rebound bar. Choose the Poplar S.

For most families, the Britax Poplar is an easy seat to recommend. Use the buttons on this page to see current colorways, and have your install checked by a certified car seat technician.

Modes
Rear-facing harness, forward-facing harness (no booster mode)
Rear-facing
5–50 lb and 18–49 in; top of head at least 1 in below the top of the head restraint
Forward-facing harness
30–65 lb and 35–49 in; tops of ears below the top of the head restraint
Lower infant insert
May be used rear-facing up to 20 lb; never forward-facing
Lower anchor (LATCH) limit
35 lb child weight, rear-facing and forward-facing
Top tether
Forward-facing only
Width
17 in (Britax)
Dimensions
20.5 x 17 x 23.5 in (Britax)
Seat weight
27.2 lb (Britax)
Recline
6 positions
Useful life
10 years
FAA
Certified for motor vehicles and aircraft
Warranty
1-year limited
Owner's manual
P15154500_A.1 (May 2025), models starting E1D22 / E1D42